Difference between Undefined, Unspecified, and Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++

C++ provides a powerful and flexible programming environment, but some aspects, such as undefined, unspecified, and implementation-defined behavior, lead to various issues in coding. These rule sets are indexed against the ISO C++ standard to depict how your program will behave across compilers, platforms, and optimization levels. So, these are important concepts that every developer must have to understand to write reliable and error-free code. In this article, we will explore undefined, unspecified, and implementation-defined behavior, their performance and portability consequences, their differences from each other, and how to avoid these behaviors in C++.

Table of Contents:

• Undefined Behavior in C++
  • Effects of Undefined Behavior in C++
  • How to Avoid Undefined Behavior in C++
• Unspecified Behavior in C++
  • Effects of Unspecified Behavior in C++
  • How to Avoid Unspecified Behavior
• Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++
  • Effects of Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++
  • How to Avoid Implementation-Defined Behavior
• Undefined vs Unspecified vs Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++
• Conclusion

Undefined Behavior in C++

Undefined Behavior (UB) in C++ is a set of program operations that do not have any requirements as to how they should be handled by the C++ standard. This means that the program will have some kind of behavior that is “unexpected”. It might crash, return incorrect results, or it might work in some cases and fail in others. The compiler also optimizes and expects that undefined behavior does not occur in the code.

Here are some common coding scenarios where undefined behavior shows up in C++ applications.

Examples of undefined behavior in C++:

1. Dereferencing a Null Pointer

int* ptr = nullptr;
*ptr = 42; // UB: Dereferencing a null pointer

2. Out-of-Bounds Array Access

int arr[3] = {1, 2, 3};
int x = arr[5]; // Accessing an out-of-bounds element
std::cout << x;  

3. Modifying a Variable Multiple Times in One Statement

int i = 5;
i = i++ + ++i; // UB: Unsequenced modifications of 'i'

4. Signed Integer Overflow

int x = INT_MAX;
x = x + 1; // Signed integer overflow

5. Using an Uninitialized Variable

int x;
std::cout << x; // Reading an uninitialized variable

6. Returning a Reference to a Local Variable

int& foo() {
    int x = 42;
    return x; // Returning reference to a local variable
}

Effects of Undefined Behavior in C++

Now that you have seen examples, here is how they can impact the reliability, performance, and security of your code.

• The program can crash unexpectedly.
• The compiler may remove or reorder the code unpredictably.
• The program can produce different results in different compilers or optimization levels.
• Also, security issues such as buffer overflows can occur.

How to Avoid Undefined Behavior in C++

Here are some best practices and modern C++ techniques to prevent it.

1. Enable the compiler warnings and C++ undefined behavior sanitizer in your compiler.

• Always use -Wall -Wextra -Wpedantic in GCC/Clang.
• Also, use the tools such as AddressSanitizer, UndefinedBehaviorSanitizer, and Valgrind.

2. You must always follow the C++ Standard. 

• Avoid changing the same variable more than once in an expression.
• Before using the variables, always initialize them.
• Ensure proper pointer safety by checking for the nullptr before dereferencing.

3. You can use other safer alternatives.

• You can use the std::vector instead of using the raw arrays to avoid out-of-bounds errors in the program.
• You can also use the std::optional to manage the uninitialized values safely.

Now that you know about undefined behavior, let’s move on to unspecified behavior and how it affects program consistency.

Unspecified Behavior in C++

Unspecified behavior in C++ is the case where the C++ standard allows multiple possible outcomes, but it does not make any outcome mandatory. Unspecified behavior does not necessarily lead to any program crash or behave unexpectedly, but it can still lead to unpredictable issues, such as in different compilers or the same compiler with different settings may give different but valid results.

To understand unspecified behavior better, let’s walk through some practical C++ examples where it might appear.

Examples of unspecified behavior in C++:

1. Order of Function Arguments Evaluation

int a = 1, b = 2;
int result = foo(a, bar(b)); //The order in which 'foo' and 'bar' are evaluated is unspecified.

2. Order of Operands in Expressions

int x = 5;
int y = x + (x = 10); //The order of evaluating x and (x = 10) is unspecified.

3. Multiple Calls to operator new() Without Storage Reuse

new int;
new int; //The standard does not specify whether the same memory location is reused.

4. The Memory Layout of Structs

struct Data {
  int a;
  char b;
  double c;
};
// The order and padding between members 'a', 'b', and 'c' are unspecified.

5. Use of std::rand() Without a Definition

int random_value = std::rand();  //The sequence of values is unspecified.

6. Using sizeof() on an Empty Class

class Empty {};
std::cout << sizeof(Empty) << std::endl;
//An empty class must have a unique address, so compilers typically assign it at least 1 byte. However, the exact size is unspecified and compiler-dependent.

Effects of Unspecified Behavior in C++

Now that you have seen examples, here is how unspecified behavior can influence the output and portability of your program.

• Different compilers can give different results for the same code.
• The same program can behave in different ways between executions.
• It can cause subtle bugs that are difficult to detect.

How to Avoid Unspecified Behavior

Let’s see how modern C++ techniques can help you prevent such issues before they even appear.

1. Always write explicit and clear expressions in the programs.

• Never rely on the order of evaluation in expressions.
• You should use the intermediate variables to make the sequence of operations clear.

2. Always check the compiler documentation.

• You must check the compiler documentation, as compilers specify their choices of unspecified behavior, which can help in debugging the code.

3. You can use the standard-define alternatives.

• The std::mt19937 from <random> can be used for random number generation instead of using the std::rand().
• Use the explicit struct layout control through #pragma pack or alignas() if it is necessary.

Apart from undefined and unspecified behavior, the C++ standard also defines implementation-defined behavior, due to which the compiler makes the choice.

Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++

Implementation-defined behavior in C++ is a case where the C++ standard makes it mandatory that the compiler must define a particular behavior, but it also allows different implementations to choose how they will behave. It allows multiple valid outcomes, but the documentation must have been done by the compiler vendor. This can create challenges in cross-platform compatibility.

Let’s look at some C++ examples where compiler decisions lead to implementation-defined behavior.

Examples of implementation-defined behavior in C++:

1. Size of Fundamental Data Types

std::cout << sizeof(int) << std::endl;  // Compiler-dependent (commonly 4 bytes, but not guaranteed)

2. Signed Right Shift

int x = -8;
  std::cout << (x >> 1) << std::endl; // Compiler-defined: most implementations use arithmetic right shift (sign-preserving), but the standard does not mandate it.

3. Character Encoding of char

char c = 'A';
  std::cout << static_cast(c) << std::endl; // ASCII (on most systems) but could be EBCDIC.

4. Null Pointer Representation

int* ptr = nullptr;

5. Byte Order of Multi-Byte Data Types

int x = 1;
if ((char)&x == 1)
   std::cout << "Little-endian" << std::endl;
else
   std::cout << "Big-endian" << std::endl;

6. Behavior of setjmp and long

include <csetjmp>
std::jmp_buf buf;
void func() {
  std::longjmp(buf, 1);
//longjmp() restores the program state to where setjmp() was called, and skipping object destruction can cause resource leaks and undefined behavior.
}

7. Alignment Requirements

struct A {
double d;
char c;
};
std::cout << alignof(A) << std::endl; // Compiler-defined alignment rules.

Effects of Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++

Here is how implementation-defined behavior can influence cross-platform development and performance.

• The code can behave differently across different compilers or platforms.
• Due to implementation-defined behavior, some optimizations and layouts can change.
• It can affect cross-platform development if not handled properly.

How to Avoid Implementation-Defined Behavior

Now, let’s see with the right strategies how you can minimize the risks of implementation-defined behavior in your C++ projects.

1. Always check the compiler documentation.

• Read the compiler manuals for choosing a particular implementation.
• You can use -dM -E with GCC/Clang to inspect predefined macros.

2. Use the standardized alternatives when it is necessary.

• Prefer the fixed-width integer types std::int32_t and std::uint64_t over the int and long.
• Use portable libraries such as Boost and the C++ standard libraries for handling system-dependent features.

3. You must write the code that can be used on cross-platforms.

• You can use the std::byte for the raw memory instead of relying on char.
• Implement the byte-order awareness for the data serialization.

Undefined vs Unspecified vs Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++

Here is a comparison table that shows the difference between undefined, unspecified, and implementation-defined behavior in C++:

Conclusion 

Getting to know undefined, unspecified, and implementation-defined behavior in C++ is an important step towards creating applications that are reliable, portable, and performant. Undefined behavior can introduce non-determinism, crashes, and severe security issues, whereas unspecified behavior can mean your code has multiple valid outputs based on implementations, and therefore makes it harder to detect subtle bugs. Implementation-defined behavior is dependent on decisions made by the compiler and can affect portability across compilers and platforms. Understanding these behaviors and how to detect, prevent, and manage them will keep your C++ code consistent, non-defective, standards-compliant, and performant across all platforms and compilers.

Useful Resources:

• Compiling and Linking in C++
• Functions in C++ Explained: Types, Syntax, and Examples
• Initialization in C++
• Arrays in C++
• As-If Rule in C++

FAQs on Undefined, Unspecified, and Implementation-Defined Behavior in C++